Craigs List Jeep Comanche For Sale: Your Ultimate Guide to Finding the Iconic MJ

Craigs List Jeep Comanche For Sale: Your Ultimate Guide to Finding the Iconic MJ jeeps.truckstrend.com

The phrase "Craigs List Jeep Comanche For Sale" often conjures images of a rugged, vintage pickup truck, a testament to an era when Jeeps were built with a unique blend of utility and unmistakable character. For enthusiasts and collectors alike, the Jeep Comanche, known internally as the MJ, isn’t just a vehicle; it’s a piece of automotive history, a workhorse with a cult following. Its blend of Cherokee (XJ) DNA with a dedicated truck bed makes it a rare and highly sought-after commodity in today’s market.

Craigslist, despite the rise of more modern online marketplaces, remains a surprisingly robust and often preferred platform for finding these elusive machines. Its local focus and direct-to-seller approach cut out intermediaries, sometimes leading to hidden gems or "barn finds" that never make it to larger, more curated sites. However, navigating the world of "Craigs List Jeep Comanche For Sale" requires a keen eye, patience, and a solid understanding of what you’re looking for. This comprehensive guide aims to equip you with the knowledge and strategies needed to successfully find, evaluate, and acquire your dream Jeep Comanche.

Craigs List Jeep Comanche For Sale: Your Ultimate Guide to Finding the Iconic MJ

The Enduring Appeal of the Jeep Comanche (MJ)

Before diving into the mechanics of buying, it’s essential to understand why the Jeep Comanche holds such a special place in the hearts of its admirers. Produced from 1986 to 1992, the MJ was essentially a unibody XJ Cherokee front end mated to a traditional ladder frame at the rear, creating a unique hybrid pickup truck. This design offered the comfort and maneuverability of the XJ, combined with the utility and towing capacity of a light-duty truck.

Its appeal stems from several key factors:

• Rugged Simplicity: Like its XJ sibling, the Comanche is known for its robust and relatively simple mechanicals, particularly when equipped with the venerable 4.0-liter inline-six engine.
• Off-Road Prowess: With solid axles and available 4×4, the MJ inherits the legendary off-road capability synonymous with the Jeep brand.
• Practicality: The pickup bed, available in 6-foot and 7-foot lengths, provides genuine utility, making it a versatile vehicle for work or play.



• Collector’s Item: With limited production numbers (around 200,000 units over its lifespan) and many having succumbed to rust or harsh use, well-preserved examples are increasingly rare and desirable.
• Modifiability: The shared architecture with the XJ Cherokee means a vast aftermarket of parts and upgrades are readily available, making it a fantastic platform for customization.

This unique combination of heritage, utility, and capability is precisely why so many enthusiasts scour "Craigs List Jeep Comanche For Sale" listings daily.

Why Craigslist for a Comanche? Unearthing Local Gems

In an age dominated by sophisticated automotive marketplaces, why does Craigslist remain a go-to for finding a Jeep Comanche?

• Local Focus: Craigslist is inherently local. For vehicles like the Comanche, which are often older and require in-person inspection, this local emphasis is crucial. It connects buyers directly with sellers in their immediate area.
• Direct Seller Interaction: You’re dealing directly with the owner, not a dealership or a third-party broker. This allows for more personal negotiation and direct questions about the vehicle’s history.



• Lower Fees/No Fees: Listing on Craigslist is often free for private sellers, meaning they don’t have to factor commission into their asking price, potentially leading to better deals for buyers.
• The "Hidden Gem" Factor: Many Comanches are sold by individuals who aren’t necessarily "car people" but simply have an old truck they want to sell. These listings might be poorly described or photographed, leading to overlooked opportunities for savvy buyers.
• Older Vehicle Niche: Craigslist excels at listing older, less mainstream vehicles that might not fit the mold of what larger platforms focus on.

Navigating Craigslist: Your Search Strategy

Finding a Comanche on Craigslist requires more than just typing "Jeep Comanche." Here’s how to optimize your search:

1. Keywords are King: Don’t just search for "Jeep Comanche." Use variations like "Jeep MJ," "Comanche pickup," "Cherokee truck," "XJ truck," "Jeep 4×4 pickup," or even misspellings like "Commache." Sellers might not know the exact nomenclature.
2. Broaden Your Radius: If your initial local search yields nothing, expand your search radius. Comanches are rare enough that a willingness to travel a few hours might be necessary.
3. Check Multiple Categories: While "Cars & Trucks" is obvious, sometimes sellers mistakenly list them under "Parts" or "Farm & Garden."
4. Frequency and Patience: New listings appear constantly. Check Craigslist multiple times a day. Set up alerts if the platform (or a third-party tool) offers this functionality.
5. Examine Listings Critically:
   • Photos: Are there multiple photos from different angles? Do they show the interior, engine bay, and undercarriage? Lack of photos or blurry ones can be a red flag.
   • Description: Is the description detailed or sparse? Look for information on mileage, engine type, transmission, 4×4 status, known issues, and recent maintenance.
   • Price: Does the price seem too good to be true? It probably is.

What to Look For: Essential Inspection Checklist for a Comanche

Once you find a promising "Craigs List Jeep Comanche For Sale" listing, a thorough inspection is paramount. Comanches are old trucks, and they come with common issues.

1. Rust (The #1 Enemy): This is the most critical factor.
   • Frame Rails: Especially where the unibody meets the frame (just behind the cab). Check for rot, patches, or severe flaking.
   • Floorboards & Rocker Panels: Inside the cab and along the body sides.
   • Bed Floor & Supports: Lift any bed liners to inspect underneath.
   • Cab Corners & Fenders: Common areas for rust to form.
   • Shock Mounts & Suspension Components: Check for structural integrity.
2. Drivetrain:
   • Engine (Primarily 4.0L I6): Listen for knocking, ticking, or excessive smoke. Check for oil leaks (rear main seal is common but not necessarily fatal). Ensure it starts easily.
   • Transmission (AW4 Automatic, AX-15 Manual): Check fluid level and color. For automatics, look for smooth shifts, no slipping. For manuals, check clutch engagement and grinding.
   • Transfer Case (NP231, NP242): Engage 4WD (Hi and Lo) to ensure it shifts properly. Listen for clunks or grinding.
   • Axles (Dana 30 front, Dana 35/44 rear): Check for leaks around the differential covers and axle seals. Listen for excessive noise during a test drive.
3. Suspension & Steering:
   • Leaf Springs: Check for sagging, especially in the rear.
   • Bushings: Inspect control arm bushings, leaf spring bushings, and sway bar bushings for wear.
   • Ball Joints & Tie Rods: Check for excessive play.
   • Steering Box: Look for leaks and excessive play in the steering wheel.
4. Electrical: Test all lights (headlights, brake lights, turn signals), wipers, horn, power windows (if equipped), and HVAC system.
5. Interior: Check for tears in seats, condition of dashboard (cracks are common), and missing trim pieces.
6. Documentation: CRITICAL! Verify the VIN on the vehicle matches the title. Ensure the title is clean (not salvage or rebuilt) and in the seller’s name. A clean, transferable title is non-negotiable.

Communicating with Sellers & The Negotiation Process

Once you’ve identified a potential Comanche, clear communication and a well-thought-out negotiation strategy are vital.

1. Initial Contact: Be polite and concise. Ask specific questions about known issues, recent maintenance, and title status. Avoid lowballing via email.
2. Schedule a Viewing: Always view the vehicle in daylight and ideally when it’s dry. Bring a knowledgeable friend if possible.
3. Test Drive:
   • Drive on various road types (city, highway, bumps).
   • Listen for unusual noises (clunks, grinding, squeaks).
   • Test brakes (pulling, sponginess).
   • Test all gears, including 4WD.
   • Check for smoke from the exhaust (blue = oil, white = coolant, black = rich fuel).
4. Negotiation:
   • Research Market Value: Look at similar Comanches that have recently sold on various platforms.
   • Identify Flaws: Use any issues discovered during inspection (rust, leaks, worn parts) to justify a lower offer.
   • Be Prepared to Walk Away: Don’t get emotionally attached. There will be other Comanches.
   • Cash in Hand: Having cash ready can give you leverage.
   • Be Realistic: A "perfect" Comanche will command a premium. A project will be cheaper but require significant investment.

Common Pitfalls and How to Avoid Them

Buying a vehicle like the Comanche on Craigslist isn’t without its risks.

• Scams: Be wary of listings that seem too good to be true, sellers unwilling to meet in person, or those asking for payment via unusual methods. Never send money before seeing the vehicle and verifying the title.
• Undisclosed Damage: Sellers may intentionally or unintentionally omit significant problems. This is why a thorough inspection is crucial.
• Salvage/Rebuilt Titles: Understand what a salvage title means in your state. It often indicates significant damage and can affect insurance and resale value. Only consider if the price is significantly lower and you understand the history.
• No NEVER buy a vehicle without a clear, transferable title in the seller’s name. Obtaining a title for an older vehicle can be an impossible headache.
• Overpaying for a "Project": Be honest about your mechanical skills and budget. A cheap Comanche might quickly become a money pit if you’re not prepared for extensive repairs.

Practical Advice and Actionable Insights

• Patience is a Virtue: Finding the right Comanche takes time. Don’t rush into a purchase.
• Set a Realistic Budget: Factor in not just the purchase price but also immediate repairs, maintenance, and potential upgrades.
• Join Online Communities: Forums like ComancheClub.com are invaluable resources for advice, parts, and understanding common issues.
• Pre-Purchase Inspection (PPI): If you’re serious about a Comanche and the seller agrees, consider having a trusted mechanic perform a PPI. This small investment can save you thousands.
• Bring a Friend: A second pair of eyes can spot things you might miss.

Craigs List Jeep Comanche For Sale: Estimated Price Guide

Please note: Prices for a "Craigs List Jeep Comanche For Sale" vary wildly based on geographic location, specific model year, engine/transmission combination, 2WD/4WD, existing modifications, and the overall "Jeep tax" in certain regions. This table provides a general estimate for a private sale.

Condition Category	Estimated Price Range (USD)	Key Characteristics & Considerations
Parts/Scrap	$500 – $1,500	Severely rusted, non-running, major drivetrain issues, no title, or only good for specific parts. Buyer beware.
Project/Rough	$1,500 – $4,000	Running but needs significant mechanical work (engine/trans issues, major leaks), heavy rust requiring fabrication, significant interior/exterior damage. Requires substantial investment.
Driver/Fair	$4,000 – $8,000	Runs and drives, passes inspection (mostly), but has noticeable rust (surface or minor perforation), cosmetic flaws, minor leaks, some deferred maintenance. Usable as a daily driver with ongoing work.
Good/Solid	$8,000 – $15,000	Minimal rust, good running 4.0L engine, functional drivetrain, decent interior, minor cosmetic blemishes. Well-maintained examples, potentially with some desirable modifications. Ready to enjoy.
Excellent/Restored	$15,000 – $30,000+	Near-showroom condition, fully restored, or exceptionally well-preserved original. No significant rust, pristine interior, fully functional and recently serviced. Rare to find on Craigslist; more likely at specialist dealers or auctions.

Disclaimer: These are rough estimates. A highly desirable configuration (e.g., 4.0L, 5-speed, 4×4, short bed) in good condition will always command a higher price.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) About Buying a Jeep Comanche on Craigslist

Q1: Is it hard to find parts for a Jeep Comanche?
A1: Generally, no. Most mechanical parts (engine, transmission, front suspension, interior) are shared with the widely available Jeep Cherokee (XJ) from the same era. Body-specific parts like the bed, rear frame section, and some unique interior bits can be harder to find, but still exist through enthusiast groups or specialty salvage yards.

Q2: What’s the best engine for a Comanche?
A2: The 4.0-liter AMC Inline-Six (I6) is by far the most desirable and reliable engine. It offers good power and torque, excellent longevity, and widespread parts availability. Early models had a 2.8L V6 or 2.5L I4, which are less powerful and less sought after.

Q3: Are Jeep Comanches reliable?
A3: When properly maintained, the 4.0L Comanches are known for their rugged reliability and longevity. Like any older vehicle, they will require ongoing maintenance, but the core components are very robust.

Q4: Can a Comanche be a daily driver?
A4: Yes, a well-maintained Comanche, especially with the 4.0L engine, can certainly serve as a daily driver. They offer a comfortable ride (for a truck of their age) and decent fuel economy for a 4×4 pickup. However, expect an older vehicle experience compared to modern trucks.

Q5: What are the most common rust spots to check?
A5: The critical rust areas are the frame rails where the unibody meets the frame (just behind the cab), floorboards, rocker panels, bed floor supports, cab corners, and around the wheel wells. Rust in these areas can be structural and costly to repair.

Q6: Should I buy a Comanche with a salvage title?
A6: Proceed with extreme caution. A salvage title means the vehicle was deemed a total loss by an insurance company. While it can lead to a lower price, it often indicates significant underlying damage (accident, flood, theft recovery) that may not be fully repaired or could lead to future issues. It can also affect insurance rates and resale value. Only consider if you’re an expert mechanic, the price is exceptionally low, and you understand the full history.

Conclusion: The Reward of the Hunt

The journey to finding a "Craigs List Jeep Comanche For Sale" is often as much about the hunt as it is about the acquisition. It requires diligence, a keen eye for detail, and a healthy dose of patience. However, for those willing to put in the effort, the reward is an iconic, capable, and increasingly rare piece of Jeep history. Owning a Comanche isn’t just about having a classic truck; it’s about joining a passionate community and enjoying a vehicle that perfectly blends utility with the unmistakable spirit of adventure. With the right approach, your next great automotive adventure might just begin with a simple Craigslist search.