Jeep Comanche For Sale NJ: Your Ultimate Guide to Finding and Owning an Iconic Pickup

Jeep Comanche For Sale NJ: Your Ultimate Guide to Finding and Owning an Iconic Pickup jeeps.truckstrend.com

The Jeep Comanche, affectionately known by enthusiasts as the "MJ," holds a unique and revered place in automotive history. Produced from 1986 to 1992, this compact pickup truck combined the rugged DNA of the beloved XJ Cherokee with the utility of a bed, creating a vehicle that was ahead of its time and remains highly sought after today. For those in the Garden State, the search for a "Jeep Comanche For Sale NJ" isn’t just about finding a used truck; it’s about uncovering a piece of American automotive heritage, a versatile workhorse, or the foundation for an ultimate off-road build.

New Jersey, with its diverse terrain ranging from coastal dunes to Appalachian foothills, and a strong culture of outdoor enthusiasts and off-roaders, represents a significant market for classic 4x4s. However, buying a vintage vehicle like the Comanche in a region prone to road salt and varied climates presents its own set of challenges and opportunities. This comprehensive guide will navigate you through the exciting journey of finding, evaluating, and ultimately owning a Jeep Comanche in New Jersey, equipping you with the knowledge to make an informed decision.

Jeep Comanche For Sale NJ: Your Ultimate Guide to Finding and Owning an Iconic Pickup

The Enduring Appeal of the Jeep Comanche

Born from the unibody platform of the highly successful Jeep Cherokee (XJ), the Comanche inherited its sibling’s robust construction, excellent off-road capability, and a surprisingly comfortable ride for a truck of its era. Unlike traditional body-on-frame pickups, the Comanche’s unibody design offered superior rigidity and a lower center of gravity, contributing to its agile handling both on and off the pavement.

Why the MJ remains a legend:

• Versatility: It perfectly bridges the gap between a compact SUV and a full-size pickup, offering a manageable footprint with practical hauling capabilities.
• Off-Road Prowess: With available Command-Trac (NP231) and Selec-Trac (NP242) four-wheel-drive systems, coupled with solid axles (Dana 30 front, Dana 35/44 rear), the Comanche is incredibly capable off-road right out of the factory.
• Durability & Simplicity: Built during an era when vehicles were designed to be repaired, not just replaced, the Comanche is known for its mechanical robustness and straightforward design, making it a favorite among DIY mechanics.
• Parts Interchangeability: A significant advantage is the vast interchangeability of parts with the ubiquitous XJ Cherokee, ensuring a steady supply of components for maintenance and upgrades.



• Classic Status: As a relatively rare vehicle (compared to the XJ), the Comanche has achieved classic status, making well-preserved examples appreciate in value among collectors and enthusiasts.

Navigating the New Jersey Market for a Comanche

Finding a Jeep Comanche for sale in New Jersey requires patience, diligence, and an understanding of the local market’s unique characteristics.

Availability and Where to Look:
Comanches are not as common as other vintage Jeeps, so dedicated searching is key.

• Online Marketplaces: Facebook Marketplace, Craigslist, and eBay Motors are primary hunting grounds. Set up search alerts for "Jeep Comanche NJ" or "Jeep MJ."
• Dedicated Forums & Communities: Websites like ComancheClub.com and various Jeep enthusiast groups on social media are excellent resources. Members often sell their MJs directly, and you can tap into a wealth of knowledge.
• Classic Car Dealerships/Specialists: Some dealerships specializing in vintage 4x4s or classic American vehicles might occasionally have a Comanche.



• Auctions: Websites like Bring A Trailer occasionally feature well-preserved or custom Comanches, though prices can be premium.
• Word-of-Mouth: Network with local Jeep clubs and off-road groups in NJ. You might hear about a potential sale before it hits the wider market.

Rust Concerns in New Jersey:
New Jersey’s climate, with its snowy winters and liberal use of road salt, poses a significant challenge for older vehicles. Rust is the primary enemy of any vintage vehicle in NJ, and the Comanche is no exception. Be prepared to scrutinize every potential purchase for signs of corrosion.

Pricing Trends in NJ:

The price of a Jeep Comanche in New Jersey can vary wildly, largely dependent on its condition, mileage, engine, drivetrain, trim level, and any modifications. A project truck might go for a few thousand dollars, while a fully restored or exceptionally clean example could fetch upwards of $20,000.

Key Considerations When Buying a Jeep Comanche in NJ

A thorough inspection is paramount when considering a Comanche. Focus on these critical areas:

1. Engine Options:

   • 2.5L AMC I4: A solid, reliable four-cylinder, but can feel underpowered. Good for economy and light duty.
   • 2.8L GM V6: Generally considered problematic. Many have been swapped out. If present, proceed with extreme caution.
   • 4.0L AMC I6 (Renix 1987-1990, High Output 1991-1992): The undisputed king. Known for its legendary durability, torque, and ease of modification. The High Output (HO) version is preferred for its increased power. This is the engine most enthusiasts seek.

2. Transmission:

   • Manual: Available with the Peugeot BA-10/5 (early models, somewhat fragile) and the much more robust Aisin AX-15 (later models, highly desirable).
   • Automatic: The Aisin-Warner AW4 is a highly reliable and popular automatic transmission, shared with the XJ Cherokee.

3. Drivetrain:

   • 2WD vs. 4WD: While 2WD Comanches exist and are often cheaper, most buyers seek the 4×4 capability that defines a Jeep. Ensure the 4WD system engages smoothly.
   • Transfer Cases: NP231 Command-Trac (part-time 4WD) is common and robust. NP242 Selec-Trac (full-time 4WD option) offers more versatility for varied conditions.

4. Rust Inspection Checklist (Crucial for NJ):

   • Frame Rails: Especially where the cab and bed meet, and near spring mounts. Look for patches, severe pitting, or bubbling.
   • Floor Pans & Rocker Panels: Common rust spots due to water and salt exposure.
   • Cab Corners & Door Sills: Check thoroughly inside and out.
   • Bed Mounts & Crossmembers: The bed itself can rust, particularly the floor and wheel wells.
   • Suspension Mounts: Control arm mounts, spring perches, and shock mounts on the axles and frame.
   • Brake Lines & Fuel Lines: Follow them along the frame for corrosion.

5. Mechanical Health:

   • Cooling System: Check for leaks, condition of hoses, and radiator. Overheating is a common XJ/MJ issue if neglected.
   • Steering & Suspension: Look for excessive play in the steering wheel, worn ball joints, tie rods, and bushings.
   • Electrical System: Test all lights, gauges, windows, and HVAC. Electrical gremlins can be frustrating.
   • Fluid Leaks: Check under the vehicle for oil, transmission fluid, coolant, or differential fluid leaks.

6. Documentation:

   • Clear Essential for a smooth transfer of ownership in NJ.
   • Maintenance Records: A history of care adds significant value and peace of mind.

7. Pre-Purchase Inspection (PPI): If you’re serious about a Comanche, invest in a PPI by a mechanic familiar with older Jeeps or off-road vehicles. They can spot issues you might miss.

Tips for a Successful Comanche Purchase in NJ

• Patience is a Virtue: The perfect Comanche won’t appear overnight. Be prepared to wait for the right one.
• Set a Realistic Budget: Factor in not just the purchase price, but also immediate repairs, deferred maintenance, and potential upgrades. A "cheap" Comanche can quickly become expensive.
• Join the Community: Engaging with local NJ Jeep clubs or online forums will provide invaluable advice, potential leads, and support after your purchase.
• Bring a Magnet: A simple magnet can help you detect bondo or excessive body filler covering rust.
• Thorough Test Drive: Drive the truck at various speeds, test the brakes, steering, and engage 4WD (if applicable) in a safe environment. Listen for unusual noises.
• Know Your Purpose: Are you looking for a daily driver, a weekend trail rig, or a restoration project? Your intended use will heavily influence what type of Comanche you should pursue.

Common Challenges and Solutions

• Rust Repair: This is often the biggest hurdle in NJ. Professional welding for frame or structural rust is recommended. Patch panels are available for common body rust areas.
• Parts Availability: While many parts are shared with the XJ Cherokee, specific Comanche parts (like the bed or specific trim pieces) can be harder to find. Online forums and dedicated salvage yards are your best bet. Aftermarket support is robust for performance parts.
• NJ Emissions Testing: Vehicles older than 25 years (and certain specific model years, generally pre-1996 for OBD-II) are often exempt from emissions testing in New Jersey. Always check the current New Jersey Motor Vehicle Commission (NJ MVC) regulations for exact exemptions based on model year.
• Finding a Reputable Mechanic: Seek out shops specializing in classic 4x4s or with experience working on older Jeeps.

Jeep Comanche For Sale NJ: Estimated Price Table (NJ Market)

The following table provides a general estimate for Jeep Comanche prices in New Jersey. Prices are highly variable and depend on specific condition, modifications, and market demand.

Condition Category	Engine	Drivetrain	Estimated Price Range (USD)	Key Characteristics & Notes
Poor / Project	2.5L/4.0L	2WD/4WD	$2,000 – $5,000	Significant rust (frame, body), major mechanical issues, non-running or barely running. Requires extensive restoration. Likely 2WD or neglected 4WD.
Fair / Driver	2.5L/4.0L	2WD/4WD	$5,000 – $9,000	Visible rust (surface/minor structural), needs repairs (brakes, suspension, leaks), interior wear. Runs and drives, but not show-ready. Often 2WD.
Good / Restored	4.0L I6	4WD	$9,000 – $15,000	Minimal rust, good running condition, solid drivetrain, functional interior. May have some aftermarket upgrades. Ready for daily driving or light trails.
Excellent / Show	4.0L I6	4WD	$15,000 – $25,000+	Near-perfect body (no rust), fully restored or meticulously maintained, low mileage, often with desirable options (Dana 44 rear, AX-15). Collector quality.

Disclaimer: These are approximate price ranges for the New Jersey market and can fluctuate significantly based on individual vehicle specifics, seller motivation, and current demand.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) about Jeep Comanche For Sale NJ

Q1: Is a Jeep Comanche a good daily driver in New Jersey?
A1: A well-maintained Comanche with the 4.0L engine can be a reliable daily driver. However, remember it’s an older vehicle; expect less refinement, modern safety features, and fuel economy compared to newer trucks. Regular maintenance is crucial.

Q2: Which engine is best for a Comanche, especially for NJ’s varying conditions?
A2: The 4.0L AMC inline-six engine (especially the High Output version from 1991-1992) is by far the most desirable. It offers excellent power, torque, and legendary reliability, making it ideal for both highway driving and off-road excursions in NJ.

Q3: Are parts hard to find for the Jeep Comanche?
A3: Most mechanical and electrical parts are shared with the highly common XJ Cherokee, so these are generally easy to find new or used. Specific Comanche body panels (like the bed or cab back) and interior trim can be challenging but not impossible to source through forums and specialized vendors.

Q4: How much rust is too much when buying a Comanche in NJ?
A4: Any rust on structural components (frame rails, suspension mounts) is a serious concern and should be professionally evaluated. Surface rust on body panels is manageable, but perforating rust that compromises integrity or is widespread will require significant, costly repairs. Avoid any Comanche with severe rust on critical structural points unless you’re prepared for major fabrication work.

Q5: What are the key things to look for during a test drive?
A5: Listen for unusual noises from the engine, transmission, and drivetrain. Check for smooth shifting (manual or automatic). Ensure the brakes are firm and stop the vehicle straight. Test the steering for excessive play. If 4WD, engage it and drive slowly to confirm it works without binding or grinding.

Q6: Is a Jeep Comanche exempt from NJ emissions testing?
A6: In New Jersey, vehicles 1995 model year and older are generally exempt from OBD-II emissions inspections. Vehicles 1970 model year and older are exempt from all emissions inspections. Always confirm the current regulations with the New Jersey Motor Vehicle Commission (NJ MVC) for the specific model year of the Comanche you are considering.

Conclusion

The pursuit of a "Jeep Comanche For Sale NJ" is more than just a transaction; it’s an entry into a passionate community and the acquisition of a truly unique vehicle. While the New Jersey climate presents challenges in the form of rust, the reward of owning an MJ—with its legendary capability, utilitarian charm, and classic appeal—is well worth the effort. By understanding the Comanche’s specific characteristics, diligently inspecting potential purchases, and leveraging the wealth of knowledge from the Jeep community, you can confidently navigate the market. Embrace the journey, and soon you might find yourself behind the wheel of one of the most distinctive and beloved compact pickups ever made, ready for whatever adventure the Garden State, or beyond, throws your way.